Jewish vegetarianism

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Activists of 'Behemla' - an organization devoted to increasing awareness of animal cruelty among ultra-orthodox Jews - World Farm Animals Day 2013

Jewish vegetarianism is the belief that following a vegetarian diet is demanded by the Torah or by other Jewish values.[1] While classical Jewish law neither requires nor prohibits the consumption of meat, Jewish vegetarians often cite Jewish principles regarding animal welfare, environmental ethics, moral character, and health as reasons for adopting a vegetarian or vegan diet.[2][3]

Ancient and Medieval Jewish Vegetarianism[edit]

Genesis 1:29 states "And God said: Behold, I have given you every herb yielding seed which is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree that has seed-yielding fruit—to you it shall be for food." Many scholars see the Torah as thereby pointing to vegetarianism as an ideal, as Adam and Eve did not partake of the flesh of animals as all humans and animals were originally commanded by God to only eat plants.[4] According to some interpretations, God's original plan was for mankind to be vegetarian, and God only later gave permission for man to eat meat in a covenant with Noah (Genesis 9:1–17) as a temporary concession because of Man's weak nature. This concessionary view of meat-consumption is based on the scriptural analysis of several Rishonim.[5]

The Torah gives precise details on how animals are to be sacrificed and slaughtered (shechita). According to Rabbis Shlomo Ephraim Luntschitz and Abraham Isaac Kook the complexity of these laws were intended to discourage the consumption of meat.[6] Kashrut may also be designed to remind Jews of the magnitude of the task undertaken in killing a living being.[7]

Some writers assert that the Jewish prophet Isaiah was a vegetarian, on the basis of passages in the Book of Isaiah that extol nonviolence and reverence for life, such as Isaiah 1:11, 11:6-9, 65:25, and 66:3. Some of these writers refer to "the vegetarian Isaiah",[8] "the notorious vegetarian Isaiah",[9] and "Isaiah, the vegetarian prophet".[10]

The pious Jewish youths Daniel, Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego became vegan according to the Bible story found in Daniel 1:8-16. At Daniel's request, the four boys were subjected to a test; they were fed vegetables and water for ten days. At the end of the ten days, the four boys were in better condition than the other boys who ate a non-vegan diet. Consequently, they remained on the vegan diet after the test concluded.[11]

According to Clement of Alexandria, Matthew the Apostle was a vegetarian. Clement wrote: "Matthew partook of seeds, and nuts, and vegetables, without flesh."[12] James the brother of Jesus of Nazareth was said to have been vegetarian. As Eusebius puts it quoting Hegesippus: "[James] drank no wine or other intoxicating liquor, nor did he eat flesh."[13] Hegesippus also stated that James did not wear wool, but only linen.

A number of ancient Jewish sects, including early Karaite sects, regarded the eating of meat as prohibited as long as Zion was in ruins and Israel in exile.[14]

A number of medieval scholars of Judaism, such as Joseph Albo and Isaac Arama, regard vegetarianism as a moral ideal, not out of a concern for animal welfare per se but out of a concern for the moral character of the slaughterer.[15] Rabbeinu Asher ben Meshullam (twelfth century theologian and Talmudic scholar, son of Meshullam ben Jacob)) was said to have never tasted meat.[16]

Modern Jewish Vegetarianism[edit]

Modern-day proponents[edit]

Rabbi Jonathan Sacks.

While most modern-day Jews are not vegetarian, a number of prominent rabbis have advocated vegetarianism or veganism. In 2017, a statement by Jewish Veg encouraging veganism for all Jews was signed by notable rabbis including Jonathan Wittenberg, Daniel Sperber, David Wolpe, Nathan Lopes Cardozo, Kerry Olitzky, Shmuly Yanklowitz, Aryeh Cohen, Geoffrey Claussen, Rami M. Shapiro, David Rosen, Raysh Weiss, Elyse Goldstein, Shefa Gold, and Yonassan Gershom.[17][18] Other notable rabbis who have promoted vegetarianism have included David Cohen (known as "Ha-Nazir"), Shlomo Goren, Irving Greenberg, Jeremy Gimpel[19], Asa Keisar[20], Jonathan Sacks[21], She'ar Yashuv Cohen, and Yitzhak HaLevi Herzog, Everett Gendler, Joseph Soloveitchik[22], and Abraham Isaac Kook. While Kook was not completely vegetarian, David Cohen wrote an influential essay, A Vision of Vegetarianism and Peace (first published in installments in 1903–04) summarizing Kook's ideas about the "coming of the new society" in which humankind becomes vegan.[23][24]

Other notable Jewish vegetarians include Shmuel Yosef Agnon, Isaac Bashevis Singer, Reuven Rivlin, Franz Kafka, Richard H. Schwartz, Jonathan Safran Foer, Aaron S. Gross, and Roberta Kalechofsky.[25]

The first Jewish-vegetarian cookbook has been compiled by Fania Lewando and was first published in 1938 in Vilnius.[26] An English translation was issued in 2015.

A number of groups promote Jewish vegetarianism:

  • The Jewish Vegetarians of North America (JVNA) was founded by Jonathan Wolf in 1975 to promote vegetarianism within the Judaic tradition.[27] JVNA produced the 2007 film A Sacred Duty under leadership of Professor Emeritus Richard H. Schwartz, then president of JVNA. In October 2015, JVNA changed its name to Jewish Veg.
  • The Shamayim V'Aretz Institute led by Rabbi Shmuly Yanklowitz promotes a vegan diet in the Jewish community through animal welfare activism, kosher veganism, and Jewish spirituality.[28]
  • The Jewish Vegetarian Society (JVS) was co-founded (briefly as the Jewish Vegetarian and Natural Health Society, before the name was abbreviated) by Vivien and Philip Pick in the 1960s with the aim of promoting a kinder society without killing animals for food.[29] Philip Pick was the first chairman of the organisation, with Maurice Norman Lester the first vice chairman and his wife Carole Lester its first secretary.
  • Amirim, an Israeli vegetarian moshav (village), was founded in 1958. The founders of Amirim were motivated to create a vegetarian village because of their love for animals and concern for animal rights, as well as for health reasons. Both religious and non-religious families live at Amirim.[30]
  • The "Concern for Helping Animals in Israel (CHAI)" animal welfare organization promotes Jewish vegetarianism;[31] CHAI's building project is named the Isaac Bashevis Singer Humane Education Center.[32]
  • Behemla is a Haredi organization that advocates against animal cruelty and promotes veganism.[33][34]
  • Anonymous for Animal Rights is an Israeli animal rights organization that promotes Jewish vegetarianism on their website[35] and has been described as a Jewish vegetarian organization.[36]
  • Vegan Friendly is an organization in Tel Aviv that works to make veganism mainstream[37], organizes an annual "Vegan Congress,"[38] and promotes the vegan celebration of Jewish holidays.[39]

Jewish vegetarianism and veganism have become especially popular among Israeli Jews. In 2016, Israel was described as "the most vegan country on Earth," as five percent of its population eschewed all animal products. That number had more than doubled since 2010, when only 2.6 percent of Israelis were either vegan or vegetarian.[40] Veganism is particularly popular in the city of Tel Aviv, which has been described as the "vegan capital of the world."[41][42]

Interest in veganism and vegetarianism has grown among Israel's diverse Jewish populations, including among secular Jews and Orthodox Jews.[43][44] The Israeli rabbi Asa Keisar is a rare example of an Orthodox rabbi who has argued that eating meat and animal byproducts is no longer permitted according to Jewish sources, because of the cruelty inflicted on animals.[45] It is more common for Orthodox rabbis to call on Jews to reduce their consumption of animal products, as when a consortium of 120 Orthodox rabbis scholars, and community leaders in Jerusalem, known as Beit Hillel, issued a paper calling on Jews to reduce meat consumption in order to alleviate animal suffering.[46]

Ethical Arguments[edit]

There are several religious and philosophical arguments used by modern Jewish vegetarians regarding the ethics of eating meat.[47] According to some, vegetarianism is consistent with the sacred teachings and highest ideals of Judaism, including compassion, health, life, conservation of resources, tzedakah, kashrut, peace, and justice. In contrast, the mass production and consumption of meat and other animal products contradicts many Jewish values and teachings, gravely harming people, animals, communities, and the environment.[48]

One mitzvah cited by vegetarians is tza'ar ba'alei hayyim; the injunction not to cause "pain to living creatures."[7] The laws of shechita are meant to prevent the suffering of animals. However, factory farming and high-speed mechanized kosher slaughterhouses have been criticized for failing to meet the essence of shechita. Jonathan Safran Foer narrated the short documentary film If This Is Kosher..., which records what he considers abuses within the kosher meat industry.[49]

Another mitzvah often cited by Jewish vegetarians is bal tashchit; the law which prohibits waste.[7] They suggest that an omnivorous diet is wasteful, since it uses 5 times more grain, 10 times more water, 15 times more land and 20 times more energy when compared to a vegan diet.[50]

Some Jewish vegetarians also stress the commandment to maintain one's health and not harm oneself (venishmartem me'od lenafshoteichem), and point to research indicating that following a vegetarian diet promotes better health.[51] Jewish vegetarians have also argued for environmental vegetarianism, pointing out that global warming, hunger and the depletion of natural resources can be lessened by a global shift to a vegetarian or vegan diet.[52][53]

Opposition to Jewish Vegetarianism[edit]

Some Orthodox rabbis have argued that it is forbidden for an individual to become a vegetarian if they do so because they believe in animal rights, but have ruled that vegetarianism is allowed for pragmatic reasons (if kosher meat is expensive or hard to come by in their area), health concerns, or for reasons of personal taste (if someone finds meat unpalatable).[54] Some believe that halakha encourages the eating of meat at the Sabbath and Festival meals; thus some Orthodox Jews who are otherwise vegetarian will nevertheless consume meat at these meals.[citation needed]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "A Case for Jewish Vegetarianism" (PDF). PETA. 
  2. ^ "Animal Welfare - Hazon". Hazon. Retrieved 2018-03-26. 
  3. ^ Mary L. Zamore, ed. The Sacred Table: Creating a Jewish Food Ethic (New York, NY: CCAR Press, 2011).
  4. ^ Kook, Avraham Yitzhak (1961). Cohen, David, ed. "A Vision of Vegetarianism and Peace" (PDF). 
  5. ^ Schwartz, Richard H. Judaism and Vegetarianism. Lantern Books. New York, 2001. pp. 1, 12, 16, 19, 188. ISBN 1-930051-24-7.
  6. ^ "The Vision of Eden: Animal Welfare and Vegetarianism" in "Jewish Law and Mysticism", Orot 2003
  7. ^ a b c Kalechofsky, Roberta. Rabbis and Vegetarianism: An Evolving Tradition. Micah Publications. Massachusetts, 1995. pp. 16, 54, 55, 65, 66, 68, 70, 71. ISBN 0-916288-42-0.
  8. ^ "Religious Quotes". Animal Liberation Front. Archived from the original on 2015-09-22. Retrieved 2016-04-01. Isaiah is ... the prophet with the most references to nonviolence and universal respect for life. ... Jesus refers to the vegetarian Isaiah more than to any other. 
  9. ^ "The Biblical Basis of Veganism". Cincinnati, Ohio: The Nazarenes of Mount Carmel. Archived from the original on 2016-04-09. Retrieved 2016-04-01. the notorious vegetarian Isaiah 
  10. ^ Braunstein, Mark Mathew (September 1980). "Vegetarianism in Art". Vegetarian Times (#40): p. 24. Isaiah, the vegetarian prophet, meant also that humans must sit with the lamb, the kid, the ox -- because humans must make peace with the animals before they can make peace with other humans. 
  11. ^ Sardi, Bill. "Vegetarian Diet". Bible for Health. Archived from the original on 2016-04-08. Retrieved 2016-04-01. And so the boys continued to eat vegetables, and exhibited unusual intelligence and the king favored them in his service. 
  12. ^ Clement of Alexandria (1994) [c. 198]. The Instructor. Book II, Chapter I -- On Eating. London: Aeterna Press. Matthew partook of seeds, and nuts, and vegetables, without flesh. 
  13. ^ "Hegesippus (Roberts-Donaldson translation)". Early Christian Writings. Peter Kirby. James, the Lord's brother, ... drank no wine or other intoxicating liquor, nor did he eat flesh 
  14. ^ Encyclopaedia Judaica, Second Edition, Volume 11, p. 788
  15. ^ Bleich, J. David (1989). Contemporary Halakhic Problems. 3. KTAV Publishing House. Archived from the original on 2012-05-18. A number of medieval scholars regard vegetarianism as a moral ideal, not because of a concern for the welfare of animals, but because of the fact that the slaughter of animals might cause the individual who performs such acts to develop negative character traits, viz., meanness and cruelty 
  16. ^ Ginzberg, Louis; Kohler, Kaufmann. "ASHER B. MESHULLAM". jewishencyclopedia.com. 
  17. ^ "Rabbinic Statement". Jewish Veg. Retrieved 2018-04-25. 
  18. ^ "74 Rabbis Urge Jewish Community to Go Vegan". VegNews.com. Retrieved 2018-03-26. 
  19. ^ "The Rise of Israel's Orthodox Vegan Movement – Tablet Magazine". www.tabletmag.com. Retrieved 2018-04-25. 
  20. ^ "The (halachic) case for veganism". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. Retrieved 2018-05-10. 
  21. ^ Sacks, Jonathan (2001-06-06). "Faith Lectures: The Messianic Idea Today". Retrieved 2016-08-19. But I can't say very much about chickens because I'm a vegetarian and I stay milchik all the time. 
  22. ^ "Vegetarianism and Judaism: The Rav's Radical View". Kol Hamevaser. 2012-02-08. Retrieved 2018-04-25. 
  23. ^ "Full text of "A Vision of Vegetarianism and Peace"". Archive.org. 1985-04-20. Retrieved 2016-01-07. 
  24. ^ "A Vision of Vegetarianism and Peace". Jewish Vegetarians of North America. 
  25. ^ Lisa Kemmerer (2012). Animals and World Religions: Rightful Relations. p. 186. 
  26. ^ Lithuanian Jewish Community: A Jewish Culinary Legend Reborn: Fania Lewando’s Vilnius, consulted 14. Juli 2018
  27. ^ Richard H. Schwartz (2001). Judaism and Vegetarianism. pp. 167–170. 
  28. ^ "The Shamayim V'Aretz Institute | מכון שמים וארץ - Home". Shamayimvaretz.org. Retrieved 2016-01-07. 
  29. ^ Richard H. Schwartz (2001). Judaism and Vegetarianism. pp. 159–161. 
  30. ^ https://our-compass.org/2013/05/30/amirim-israel-the-worlds-first-vegan-village
  31. ^ Schwartz, Richard. "excerpt from the article "Judaism and Vegetarianism"". Retrieved April 15, 2013. 
  32. ^ "I.B. Singer Humane Education Center". CHAI. Archived from the original on 2014-07-14. ... construction on the Isaac Bashevis Singer Humane Education Center, on the grounds of the SPCA in Tel Aviv-Jaffa, is at last set to begin. 
  33. ^ "In for some vegan shoes or vegan condoms?". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. Retrieved 2018-04-18. 
  34. ^ "Israelis growing hungry for vegan diet | Jewish Telegraphic Agency". www.jta.org. Retrieved 2018-04-18. 
  35. ^ "Animal Rights and Judaism : Anonymous for Animal Rights". anonymous.org.il. Retrieved 2018-04-18. 
  36. ^ Schwartz, Richard H. (2001). Judaism and Vegetarianism. Lantern Books. p. 165. ISBN 9781930051249. 
  37. ^ "Vegan-Friendly | משדרגים את התרבות הטבעונית בארץ". www.vegan-friendly.co.il. Retrieved 2018-04-18. 
  38. ^ "Tel Aviv hosts 5th annual Vegan Congress". Israel21c. Retrieved 2018-04-18. 
  39. ^ "Vegan-Friendly | חגים ואירועים". www.vegan-friendly.co.il. Retrieved 2018-04-18. 
  40. ^ Rachel Frazin, "How Israel Became the Global Center of Veganism"," September 2016, Retrieved 2018-03-26.
  41. ^ "This is the vegan capital of the world". The Independent. Retrieved 2018-06-18. 
  42. ^ "Tel Aviv Crowned World's Vegan Capital – Tablet Magazine". www.tabletmag.com. Retrieved 2018-06-18. 
  43. ^ "The Rise of Israel's Orthodox Vegan Movement". Tablet Magazine. Retrieved 2018-03-26. 
  44. ^ Holmes, Oliver (2018-03-17). "'There is no kosher meat': the Israelis full of zeal for going vegan". the Guardian. Retrieved 2018-03-26. 
  45. ^ ""לגרוס אפרוחים בני יומם בשביל כסף? זו לא יהדות"". ynet (in Hebrew). 2016-10-02. Retrieved 2018-06-18. 
  46. ^ "The Rise of Israel's Orthodox Vegan Movement". Tablet Magazine. Retrieved 2018-03-26. 
  47. ^ "Judaism and Vegetarianism - A Vegetarian View of the Torah". Jewishveg.com. Retrieved 2016-01-07. 
  48. ^ Dan Brook, Ph.D. "The Vegetarian Mitzvah". 
  49. ^ Foer, Jonathan Safran. "If This Is Kosher…". YouTube. 
  50. ^ "Bal tashchit ('do not destroy')". Reformjudaism.org.uk. 2016-02-24. Retrieved 2016-08-19. ... an omnivorous diet (one that includes meat) is wasteful and should be prohibited, since an omnivorous diet uses five times as much grain, over ten times as much water, over 15 times as much land and over 20 times as much energy as compared with a vegan diet. 
  51. ^ Richard Schwartz, "Jewish Teachings on Health," https://www.jewishveg.org/schwartz/jhealth1.html
  52. ^ Felicity Carus (2 June 2010). "UN urges global move to meat and dairy-free diet". The Guardian. 
  53. ^ Richard Schwartz, "Jewish Environmental Teachings," https://www.jewishveg.org/schwartz/jenviro.html
  54. ^ "Judaism and Vegetarianism". aishcom. Retrieved 2018-03-26. 

Further reading[edit]

External links[edit]